Skip navigation

The wrong cure

Economic myths and realities

Our guide to current economic myths – and the essential articles and blogs that debunk them. Let us know if we've missed anything.

MYTH 1: The government's deep, rapid spending cuts are the best (or only) way to shrink the deficit.

REALITY: Cameron's government inherited a growing economy and falling deficit. Since then the economy has stagnated and the deficit has grown.


MYTH 2: Osborne has saved us from the same fate as Ireland, Portugal and Greece.

REALITY: Britain wasn't in the same position as Ireland, Portugal or Greece to start with. But by mimicking their failed austerity policies, Osborne is taking us closer to economic disaster.


MYTH 3: The cuts aren’t that bad.

REALITY: Pro-cuts commentators fiddle the figures by adding the "costs of recession" – extra debt interest and dole payments – onto public service spending. Strip out the former and it's clear the latter is being cut savagely. 


MYTH 4: Government policies are promoting growth.

REALITY: Official figures show the government has strangled a tentative recovery. GDP forecasts have been repeatedly revised down, and the government's "pro-growth" initiatives are feeble.


MYTH 5: The government is rebalancing the economy and will make us less dependent on debt.

REALITY: Osborne claims to be against high levels of both public and private debt. But official forecasts for increased growth rely on us taking on much more personal debt.


MYTH 6: Increased exports will compensate for cuts.

REALITY: "Export-led recovery" sounds like a great idea. So great, in fact, that everyone wants to do it – and therein lies the problem. Furthermore, the UK's main export markets are failing economies like Ireland.


MYTH 7: The government is tackling the banks with the same urgency that it is cutting the public sector.

REALITY: Osborne's bark has proved much worse than his bite when it comes to clamping down on obscene bonuses or structural reform to avoid another banking crash.


MYTH 8: The current crisis is the result of the last government's overspending.

REALITY: As the graph in our "How big is the deficit?" section shows, it was the recession – and the resulting collapse in tax receipts – that caused the deficit to soar. 


MYTH 9: Britain's public debt is exceptionally high – historically and in comparison with other countries.

REALITY: Neither claim is true, as illustrated by our “How big is the problem?” graphs and the links below.

MYTH 10: The theory of "expansionary fiscal contraction" explains how cuts will help the economy grow.

REALITY: Even the IMF – in a comprehensive study – found the evidence for this threadbare.


MYTH 11: The way to promote growth is to cut workers' pay and conditions.

REALITY: Analysts from across the political spectrum agree that falling wages for those on low-to-middle incomes helped cause the crash.


MYTH 12: Spending cuts are less harmful to the economy than tax rises.

REALITY: Official figures show spending cuts have a larger impact on GDP than tax rises. They also show policies that take money away from lower earners hit the economy harder than those that target high earners.


MYTH 13: Corporation tax cuts promote growth.

REALITY: Osborne's keenness for corporation tax cuts sits oddly with his professed concern over the deficit. There are arguments for other tax cuts – like VAT – but research shows only a weak relationship between corporation tax and growth.


MYTH 14: The 50p tax rate on earnings over £150,000 will lead to a lower tax take for the Treasury.

REALITY: Advocates of this argument assume a substantial number of high-rate taxpayers will leave the UK due to this tax. There is no evidence for this.


MYTH 15: Global opinion agrees with Nick (and George and Dave).

REALITY: Many other governments and international organisations – even conservative ones – balk at the UK's dash for austerity.


MYTH 16: We can't blame the government for our stagnating economy – other countries are in the same boat.

REALITY: Britain has slid down the global growth table and now languishes near the bottom.


MYTH 17: We’re all in this together.

REALITY: Our section on "How cuts will make Britain more unfair" summarises the unequal effect of the cuts, with more detail provided by the links below.



Cuts are not the cure
Download a printable pdf summary of this section.
Play video: Why cuts are the wrong cure
VIDEO: Why cuts are the wrong cure